Michigan Legislature - Act of
5 In the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws . Residential landlord-tenant relationships are governed by the FRLTA, but it does not apply .. See generally Alexander, Drafting Exculpatory Clauses in a Landlord-Tenant Relationship, 21 U. MIAMI L. REV. Lambert, F. Supp ( M.D. Fla. (); Siegel, Is the Modern Lease a Contract or a Conveyance. 7 Yet the relation of regulatory landlord-tenant law to the supply and The. District of Columbia Rental Housing Conversion and Sale Miami and. residential landlord-tenant relationship, substitutes modern contractual principles for archaic . STAT. § (). Similar provisions are found in Hawaii Laws , Act .. Lambert, F. Supp. (M.D. Fla. ).
Failure to comply with this requirement relieves the landlord of the requirement of notice of damages but does not prejudice a tenant's subsequent claim for the security deposit.
If a landlord claims damages to a rental unit and gives notice of damages as required, the tenant upon receipt of the list of damages shall respond by ordinary mail to the address provided by the landlord as required by section 3 within 7 days, indicating in detail his agreement or disagreement to the damage charges listed.
For the purposes of this section the date of mailing shall be considered the date of the tenant's response. A landlord shall not be entitled to retain any portion of a security deposit for damages claimed unless he has first obtained a money judgment for the disputed amount or filed with the court satisfactory proof of an inability to obtain service on the tenant or unless: Failure of the landlord to comply fully with this section constitutes waiver of all claimed damages and makes him liable to the tenant for double the amount of the security deposit retained.
Upon termination of a landlord's interest in a rental unit whether by sale, assignment, death, appointment of receiver or otherwise, the landlord or his agent is liable with respect to the security deposit, until the occurrence of any of the following: This act takes effect April 1, and applies only to security deposits held pursuant to leases entered into, renewed or renegotiated after April 1, Tenants cannot legally be evicted for any reason whatsoever, including nuisance and waste, while their escrow payments are current.
Leases, oral or written, are extended as necessary until the unfit designation is removed. The Act is remedial insofar as it allows a tenant to use the escrowed rent to make repairs, and punitive insofar as it penalizes a landlord for allowing the premises to fall into such a state of disrepair by depriving him or her of any profits from the premises.
It became effective in September The Philadelphia City Ordinance identified as Title 4 of the Philadelphia Code, Subcode PM, sectionrequires that a landlord, prior to renting a residential property in Philadelphia, obtain from the Department of Licenses and Inspections a certificate stating that there are no recorded code violations on the property. The landlord must also attest that all fire protection and smoke detection equipment is in proper operating order and in compliance with the Philadelphia Code; that the property is free from defects that affect the habitability livability of the property, and that the landlord will continue to maintain the property in the future, free of any defects that affect the habitability livability of the property.
The landlord must provide a copy of the certificate to the tenant. It is also illegal for any landlord to try to evict tenants by force, by turning off their utilities, by removing their possessions, by boarding up their doors or windows, or by any other means designed to force the tenant to vacate their home, unless the legal eviction process has been followed. If there is no evidence of an Alias Writ of Possession or Writ of Possession, the landlord may not evict the tenant.
If a landlord, or their agent sinsists that a tenant should be evicted without providing evidence of Writs the tenant can double check by telephoning the Philadelphia Municipal Court Judgment and Petition Unit. The court can usually tell the tenant if the landlord received a judgment in court which would allow an eviction, as well as, if and when the Writs of Possession were issued.
If there is no proof the landlord obtained an Alias Writ or Writ of Possession through the legal process, the lockout may be illegal and the tenant may have the right to return to his or her home. Using the Police A City Ordinance directs the police in Philadelphia to help tenants faced with illegal lockouts, or any action defined as a self-help eviction.
The law is Philadelphia Code It was passed by Philadelphia City Council in November In addition to defining illegal lockouts, the ordinance also defines self-help evictions as follows: Such self-help eviction practices include, but are not limited to, the following activity: If a landlord locks a tenant out illegally or engages in a self-help eviction practice, the tenant may call A police officer should respond to any complaint about an illegal lockout or self-help eviction.
The officer may ask a tenant to prove there is a written lease between the tenant and the landlord. If there is no written lease, a verbal lease may still exist, and that may be established if the tenant is able to produce a rent receipt, or other proof of payment to the landlord. If the landlord is present, the police should ask the landlord for a copy of the Alias Writ of Possession or Writ of Possession that was served by a sheriff or a landlord tenant officer.
If the landlord cannot produce any kind of Writ, the police should inform the tenant that they are entitled to re-enter their home, and tell the landlord to restore access, turn on the utilities, etc.
If the landlord refuses to let the tenant back in, or restore utility service, etc. This may result in a criminal hearing. It is possible that a police officer who responds to a tenant s complaint may not be familiar with the law. This would be analogous to the situation in which the landlord claims the total amount of a security deposit as liquidated damages. The courts allow only the amount of actual damages and hold any excess to be a penalty and not recoverable.
Interestingly, the Florida Legislature imposed a requirement of an acceptable reason for evictions from mobile home parks, thus changing hundreds of years of common law. It has been held that a tenant who holds over as to part of the premises holds over as to all of it. STAT 1 Wagner v. Town of Groveland, 79 So. The landlord's duty to repair, often called an "implied warranty of habitability," has been imposed in a number of jurisdictions by judicial decision Also, various exceptions to the caveat emptor doctrine have been carved out by the courts in special circumstances.
The trial court granted a motion to strike the affirmative defenses. On direct appeal to the Supreme Court of Florida, the lower court was affirmed without opinion. The common law rule that the landlord had no duty to repair was based upon the concept that a lease was a conveyance of real property for a term.
Michigan Security Deposits
Keaton, No Dade County Civ. See note 91 and accompanying text supra H. It has, however, become inappropriate for contemporary times when the dwelling may be of primary importance.
Also included are local building and health or sanitation codes, state statutes,' 1 24 and state administrative regulations. These codes are penal, giving to the government the right to prosecute the landlord for failure to comply.
They do not give the tenant remedies The FRLTA also provides that when there are no applicable codes, structural components and plumbing must be maintained in good 12 - repair. In an important compromise, section 1 c was added on the floor of the House. Lawsch2 1 a Fla. Lawsch2 1 See, e. Of course, the provisions of the code are subject to judicial scrutiny. City of Jacksonville, So. STATE. See also 24 U. Lawsch2 1 b.
The limitation of this paragraph to areas "where there are no applicable building, housing or health codes," was not in the original proposal, and was added in an amendment on the Senate floor.
This provision was originally intended to serve as a minimum standard regardless of where the premises were located Fla. Lawsch2 1 c. These waivers should be strictly construed against the landlord"' and, in appropriate circumstances, a tenant who has been required to sign a waiver could argue that it is unenforceable because it is unconscionable or because it is not supported by consideration e. In the event that both subsection 1 and subsection 2 impose a duty upon the landlord, subsection 1 governs.
Tenant's Obligation to Maintain Dwelling Unit It is a familiar common law doctrine that the tenant has a duty to tenance obligations with regard to any dwelling unit. The compromise amendment was worded differently from The final language was adopted by the Senate Consumer Affairs Committee.
Dade County, 33 Fla. Lawsch2 2provides: Lawsch2 4 Fla. Its main thrust is to prevent actual destruction of the premises' structural components. Consequently, the tenant's duty is customarily increased through the use of lease provisions. For example, the Model Apartment Lease imposes extensive duties of care on the tenant. See also 2 BoYR National Bank, So.
There the plaintiff sought to enjoin the defendant from making alterations in the leased building by constructing partitions on the interior and making some large openings in the exterior walls. Applying the common law rule, the court said "any alterations of the buildings on leased premises by a tenant" constitute waste.
This was true even if the alteration was beneficial to the premises See, e. This provides a set of tenant obligations such as compliance with local codes and landlord rules, and repairing damage caused by the tenant. Terms of the lease imposing a duty upon a tenant will of course vary according to the tenant's bargaining power and the imagination of the landlord's counsel. A landlord may also incorporate by reference in the lease a set of rules designed to supersede the doctrine of waste.
Tenant's obligation to maintain dwelling unit. The tenant at all times during the tenancy shall: Thus the FRLTA specifies a tenant's minimum obligation, which can be increased by the rental agreement. The tenant's maintenance obligations may not be waived. A statewide health code could be promulgated to avoid the problems arising from the failure of some local governments to establish health standards.
But landlords and tenants have always been subject to these codes, though strict enforcement has been seldom observed. Enforcement formerly was left to a "building official ' ' 14 6 or "rehabilitation officer. Another of the tenant's obligations is to "keep all plumbing fixtures in the dwelling unit or used by the tenant clean and sanitary, and in property therein belonging to the landlord, nor permit any person to do so; and 7 conduct himself and require other persons on the premises with his consent to conduct themselves in a manner that does not unreasonably disturb his neighbors or constitute a breach of the peace.
Lawsch2 1 a any provision that purports to waive or preclude the rights, remedies or requirements set forth is void Fla. The landlord is required to "[c]omply with the requirements of applicable building, housing and health codes. It requires the landlord to "maintain the plumbing in reasonable working condition.
The dilemma is manifest. When the plumbing malfunctions, whose duty is it to make repairs? One possible construction of the statute is that the words "keep all plumbing fixtures This interpretation is consistent with the overall scheme of the statute's imposing on the landlord a duty to maintain structural components in good repair.
Tenants' duties, on the other hand, require only the reasonable maintenance and operation of facilities. Thus it is unlikely that the legislature intended to impose on the tenant the cost of plumbing repairs. Absent this construction, the three words "and in repair" must be dismissed as a carelessly enacted amendment to H.
R The bill as drafted by the Law Revision Council and introduced in the House of Representatives did not bear this language. Under the FRLTA, the tenant has an obligation to "conduct himself and require other persons on the premises with his consent to conduct themselves in a manner that does not unreasonably disturb his neighbors or constitute a breach of the peace.Security Deposit Basics – Florida Landlord-Tenant Law and Florida Renter’s Rights
Lawsch2 7. Landlords typically regulate tenant conduct by the use of rules incorporated by reference into the lease or by provisions in the lease itself.
The FRLTA establishes a statutory duty for each tenant with respect to every other tenant to refrain from unreasonable disturbances.
Human Relations Commission LANDLORD & TENANT HANDBOOK
Presumably a breach of this duty would give rise to a cause of action by the disturbed tenant. What constitutes an unreasonable disturbance will be one of those difficult questions of fact with which the law is so accustomed to dealing.
Overly sensitive tenants will hopefully be deterred from frivolous complaint by the cost and bother of litigation and by the chance that their offender's conduct has not been an "unreasonable" disturbance. Consequently, section 7 will complement apartment rules and supply a statutory minimum code of conduct.
Retaliatory Conduct by the Landlord The term "retaliatory eviction" was unknown at common law and is only of recent origin in its application to landlord-tenant law. It is the practice by a landlord of evicting-or threatening to evict-a tenant who has reported housing or sanitary code violations to the public authorities or who has engaged in activities thought by the landlord to be inimical to him.
The term is new in landlord-tenant law only because in the past such evictions were not challenged. The covenant of quiet enjoyment was originally an express covenant of a lease.
Courts soon began to hold that in the absence of an express covenant, every lease has an implied covenant of reasonable and quiet enjoyment.
The effect of the presumption was merely to require the landlord to come forward with evidence of some bona fide reason for his action. Without the rebuttable presumption clause, the prohibition of retaliatory conduct by the landlord was practically unenforceable.